Japanese Stocks and the Impact of Low Interest RatesEquity analysts that work for the big banks have it relatively easy when it comes to economic forecasts. They can always use the projections of their in-house economist and, assuming his forecasts isn't off in left field, know that they won't be too harshly criticized when those assumptions turn out wrong.The rest of us aren't so fortunate. We can of course use consensus estimates, but that's a cop-out if forecasts are all over the map. Thus it's always disconcerting to read doomsday scenarios that are given credence by people who are a lot smarter in these matters than we are.
Some see looming disaster because of the
giant credit bubble that Japan's low interest-rates are creating. There's been a great deal of talk of the "carry trade," ie, borrowers taken loads of cheap yen and investing them in higher-yielding currencies. One economist cited believes that the yen is as much as
29% undervalued. Eventually, the bubble will burst, exchange rates will realign, and the yen will appreciate to 100 yen -- even 70 yen -- to the dollar. In this scenario, even the offsetting advantages of cheaper imports would be insufficient to stem a sharp, broad decline in world and Japanese business conditions. While the authors don't explictly say so, it's hard to imagine that Japanese stocks would do well in such an environment.
It's a substantially different economic world over at
Business Week. Although the piece on "low, low rates" naturally focuses on the US rather than Japan, there's no prognosis of the burst of a giant credit bubble. While cautioning about the impact low interest rates worldwide are having on credit quality, overall the article is positive. Companies are investing, profits are booming, and housing is making the all-desirable soft landing.
In the scenario seen by authors Michael Mandel and David Henry, the sources of excess liquidity are India and China (the BOJ isn't mentioned). These countries are very good at raising capital but very bad at allocating it. Thus the funds thereflow overseas. Coupled with the overall globalization of financial markets and the increasing sophistication of financial instruments (notably in the form of collateralized debt obligations), the real cost of capital continues to decline. The authors expect the low-interest rate environment to continue.
Getting back to Japan, according to a recent article in the
FT, market observers continue to be bullish on the Japanese economy. And they expect 2007 to be a much better year for stocks than 2006. (Although that may not be so great for other world markets, since the Japanese bourse tends to have its own drummer.)
As I said, we like to focus on Japanese companies, not her role in the world economy. It's a sandbox I'm not comfortable playing in.
Still, a couple of gut-feel thoughts:
(1) If you look at a five year yen/dollar chart, the trading range is about 132 (beginning of '03) to 103 (end of '04). A rate of 121 or 122 just doesn't feel like a number that's so out of whack that it would have the dire consequences the pessimists believe.
(2) Despite all the talk about Japan's recovery, there shouldn't be any sense of irrational exuberance. Consumer spending has been up a bit lately, but overall it remains lackluster. Real estate prices have firmed, but except perhaps for a few pockets of Tokyo, they're hardly raging. Since January 2006, the Nikkei has stayed in the 16,000/17,000 trading range. Putting aside Japan's longer-term debt problems, which are considerable, the environment doesn't call for a huge rise in interest rates by the BOJ.
(3) Japan's exporters operate under their own economic law. They have made money at rates of 120 and 100 yen to the dollar, and if they had to do it at 90 yen, they would. I'm worried about people no longer buying Sony because of a declining reputation for creativity and quality, not because in a strong yen environment they wouldn't figure out how to make their stuff cheaper in the globalized workshop.
The upshot is that I don't see a wild surge in the yen and, even if it occurred, the Japanese economy and markets would react a lot better than some people expect they would.