The Comsn Affair
Comsn is a nationwide nursing home operator that has given false information when applying for permits to open new facilities; it has also been receiving benefits illegally. In consequence, the central government has decided that it will not renew the operating licenses of over 80% of its nursing care centers when they expire in 2011, and it has been asked by authorities to return funds it received illegally.
Comsn is part of the Goodwill Group, which offers services in areas stretching from staffing to pet care. It is run by Masahiro Origuchi, who is both admired and disliked for employing aggressive business tactics not usually seen in Corporate Japan. He initially made his fame at 30 by opening the trend-setting disco Juliana in Tokyo. He eventually lost control, but a few years later started the Goodwill temp and recruiting company and made it into a big business.
On June 11, Goodwill decided to sell off all of its troubled subsidiaries in the nursing-care business, setting off a scramble to acquire the assets. Origuchi hoped to sell them to a single company, but with Comsn operating over 2,000 facilities and providing a wide variety of eldercare services, that does not appear to be the most likely outcome.
Among the names of suitors that have appeared in press reports are Nichii Gakkan, Watami, Tsukui Corp., Japan Care Services, Bennesse, Saint-Care Holding, and Welcia Kanto Co. coupled with Wisnet. In all, Goodwill has received proposals from over 30 companies. It expects to make a decision on asset sales by the end of July.
The Comsn scandal should be considered in light of Japanese attitudes toward eldercare. Traditionally, the aged have been taken care of by their families, particularly daughters and daughters-in-law, and nursing homes have had a small role. Moreover, much elderly care in Japan takes place in hospitals, which historically have had far more hospital beds per capita than the US. Thus the nursing home business has an uncomfortable place in Japanese society; even younger Japanese women who reject their traditional obligations toward parents may hesitate about putting them in a home. The Comsn scandal will do little to calm their anxieties.
Comsn is a nationwide nursing home operator that has given false information when applying for permits to open new facilities; it has also been receiving benefits illegally. In consequence, the central government has decided that it will not renew the operating licenses of over 80% of its nursing care centers when they expire in 2011, and it has been asked by authorities to return funds it received illegally.
Comsn is part of the Goodwill Group, which offers services in areas stretching from staffing to pet care. It is run by Masahiro Origuchi, who is both admired and disliked for employing aggressive business tactics not usually seen in Corporate Japan. He initially made his fame at 30 by opening the trend-setting disco Juliana in Tokyo. He eventually lost control, but a few years later started the Goodwill temp and recruiting company and made it into a big business.
On June 11, Goodwill decided to sell off all of its troubled subsidiaries in the nursing-care business, setting off a scramble to acquire the assets. Origuchi hoped to sell them to a single company, but with Comsn operating over 2,000 facilities and providing a wide variety of eldercare services, that does not appear to be the most likely outcome.
Among the names of suitors that have appeared in press reports are Nichii Gakkan, Watami, Tsukui Corp., Japan Care Services, Bennesse, Saint-Care Holding, and Welcia Kanto Co. coupled with Wisnet. In all, Goodwill has received proposals from over 30 companies. It expects to make a decision on asset sales by the end of July.
The Comsn scandal should be considered in light of Japanese attitudes toward eldercare. Traditionally, the aged have been taken care of by their families, particularly daughters and daughters-in-law, and nursing homes have had a small role. Moreover, much elderly care in Japan takes place in hospitals, which historically have had far more hospital beds per capita than the US. Thus the nursing home business has an uncomfortable place in Japanese society; even younger Japanese women who reject their traditional obligations toward parents may hesitate about putting them in a home. The Comsn scandal will do little to calm their anxieties.